Amy Howe

Aug 19 2020

Native American inmate asks court to stay execution

The only Native American on federal death row has asked the Supreme Court to put his death sentence on hold. In a filing submitted Tuesday, Lezmond Mitchell urged the justices to stay his execution, scheduled for Aug. 26, while they consider whether to take up his claim that he should be able to interview the jurors who convicted him about whether their deliberations were tainted by racial bias.

Mitchell, a Navajo man, was convicted of the 2001 carjacking and stabbing deaths of Alyce Slim and her nine-year-old granddaughter, who were also Navajos. After he used Slim’s pickup truck in an armed robbery on the Navajo reservation, Mitchell was arrested; he then directed Navajo police officers to the victims’ mutilated bodies.

Mitchell was tried in federal court in 2003 before a jury made up of 11 white people and one Native American. Prosecutors told the jury that, in the Old West, Mitchell “would have been taken out back” and “strung up.” He was sentenced to death, and his death sentence was upheld on appeal.

In 2018, Mitchell sought to reopen his post-conviction proceedings in the wake of the Supreme Court’s 2017 decision in Peña-Rodriguez v. Colorado. In that case, the justices – by a vote of 5-3 – created an exception when there is evidence of racial bias to the general rules barring jurors from testifying about statements made during deliberations that might call a verdict into question. A federal trial court denied Mitchell’s motion to reopen the case, reasoning that Peña-Rodriguez does not give Mitchell the right to interview his jurors unless there is a reason to believe they were biased against him. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit upheld that decision.

Mitchell went to the Supreme Court this week, asking the justices to weigh in on whether, in death penalty cases, district courts can prohibit inmates from interviewing jurors about racial bias during deliberations. He also asked them to block his execution while they consider his petition for review.

If the justices decline to intervene, Mitchell would be the fourth federal inmate executed this year after a hiatus of nearly 20 years. The battle over the federal government’s efforts to resume executions has been a hotly contested one, with inmates raising challenges specific to their cases as well as challenges to the new lethal-injection protocol that the Department of Justice devised to avoid problems obtaining the drugs that have historically been used to put inmates to death.

Correction: An earlier version of this story misstated the vote count in Peña-Rodriguez v. Colorado. The vote was 5-3, not 5-4.

This post is also published on SCOTUSblog.

Amy L Howe
Until September 2016, Amy served as the editor and reporter for SCOTUSblog, a blog devoted to coverage of the Supreme Court of the United States; she continues to serve as an independent contractor and reporter for SCOTUSblog. Before turning to full-time blogging, she served as counsel in over two dozen merits cases at the Supreme Court and argued two cases there. From 2004 until 2011, she co-taught Supreme Court litigation at Stanford Law School; from 2005 until 2013, she co-taught a similar class at Harvard Law School. She has also served as an adjunct professor at American University’s Washington College of Law and Vanderbilt Law School. Amy is a graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and holds a master’s degree in Arab Studies and a law degree from Georgetown University.
Tweets by @AHoweBlogger
Recent ScotusBlog Posts from Amy
  • Court rules for deaf student in education-law case
  • Parties disagree over court’s power to reach decision in election law case
  • Justices throw out lower-court ruling allowing state court clerk to be sued in parental notification abortion case
More from Amy Howe

Recent Posts

  • Court rules for deaf student in education-law case
  • Parties disagree over court’s power to reach decision in election law case
  • Justices throw out lower-court ruling allowing state court clerk to be sued in parental notification abortion case
  • Justices decline to halt execution of Texas man with intellectual disability claim
  • Justices take up case on federal admiralty law, seek government’s views on two pending petitions
Site built and optimized by Sound Strategies